Appointment reminders reduce missed visits, and reminders that reach the patient directly are associated with the lowest no-show rates. Evidence that a pre-appointment questionnaire reduces no-shows by itself is thin. Send the questionnaire with the reminder and use it to prepare the session. Treat noncompletion as a prompt for outreach, and measure the effect on attendance in your own clinic.
What the evidence shows for reminders
A 2011 systematic review of 29 studies covered telephone and text reminders for hospital outpatient appointments. Non-attendance fell by a weighted mean of 34% relative to baseline. Manual phone calls did better than automated reminders, with reductions of 39% and 29% of the baseline rate. A 2016 review by McLean and colleagues found that all types of reminder improved attendance across a range of settings and patient groups. It also found that reminders may increase cancellation and rescheduling of appointments patients no longer want. A cancelled slot can be offered to someone else.
Whether the reminder reaches the patient makes a difference. In a quality improvement study of 250 primary care patients with depression, the no-show rate varied by call outcome. It was 3% after a live reminder call, 24% after a voicemail, and 39% when no one answered. That is an association, because patients who are easy to reach may also be more likely to attend. A randomized study at Kaiser Permanente Washington targeted visits at high predicted no-show risk. A second text reminder lowered the risk of a missed mental health visit by about 11% (relative risk 0.89).
What a pre-appointment questionnaire adds
The McLean review describes "reminder plus" messages, which add information beyond the date, time, and place. It suggests they may reduce non-attendance more than simple reminders in some circumstances. A questionnaire link is one way to add content to a reminder. Its effect on attendance should be tested rather than assumed.
One direct test comes from a multidisciplinary pediatric chronic pain clinic. Frye and colleagues (2022) introduced a pre-appointment survey and reminder calls for new patients. The overall show rate was 73.7% before and 75.6% after, a difference that was not statistically significant. Within the later group, 97.2% of patients who completed the survey attended, compared with 36.2% of those who did not.
That gap is an association. Families who complete a survey may already be more likely to attend, so the result does not show that the survey caused attendance. It does suggest that noncompletion can identify appointments worth a follow-up call. The clinical case for the questionnaire is separate: the clinician has symptom data before the session and can use the visit to discuss it.
Design the request
Keep the request short. The item count sets the length:
- PHQ-9 alone: 9 scored questions
- PHQ-9 and GAD-7: 16 scored questions
- PHQ-2 and GAD-2 as a first-stage screen: 4 questions
Both full questionnaires ask about the past two weeks, so sending them a day or two before the visit barely changes the recall window. Choose the send time around your review workflow, because the result has to arrive before the clinician prepares for the session. Start with one send time and adjust it using your own completion data.
Tell the patient what to do, how many questions there are, when the appointment is, and that their clinician will review the answers. For example: "Please answer 16 short questions before your appointment tomorrow at 2 PM. Your clinician will review your answers before the session." Leave the condition out of the message, because email and text previews can appear on shared devices or lock screens.
If the request includes the PHQ-9, someone must review it on the day the answers arrive, even when the appointment is days away. Item 9 asks about thoughts of death or self-harm. Any answer above zero needs same-day clinician follow-up under the practice's safety protocol.
If you need help now. In the US, Call 988 or text 988. Call 911 if you are in immediate danger. Outside the US, contact your local emergency number or find support in your country.
Follow up on noncompletion
Noncompletion has several possible causes. The message may have failed or the contact details may be wrong. The patient may be unsure about attending, symptoms may have made the task harder, or the link may not have worked. Do not read silence as a low score or as a sign the patient is well.
Send one reminder with a direct link. If the questionnaire is still incomplete on the morning of the appointment, have staff call. The call can confirm the visit, ask about barriers, and offer to complete the questions by phone or at check-in. Track patterns per patient. Some patients never complete the questionnaire but always attend, while others miss both.
Ask about barriers
Add one question that gives staff time to act: "Is there anything that might make it hard to attend your appointment tomorrow?" Offer options such as transport, a schedule conflict, feeling too unwell to come, or worry about the appointment, plus a free-text field. Route any selected barrier to staff who can call the patient, offer a different time, or offer a video visit if the service provides one.
For ongoing patients, an optional question such as "What would you like to focus on in tomorrow's session?" gives the clinician an agenda before the visit.
Shorten the wait for first appointments
At a community mental health center, Gallucci and colleagues (2005) found that longer delays before the initial appointment significantly reduced the rate of kept appointments. The effect was concentrated in the first week of delay and appeared to level off after day seven. If first-visit no-shows are the main problem, look at the booking delay as well as the reminder.
Measure the effect locally
Before changing anything, record the baseline no-show rate overall, by clinician, and by appointment type. Define no-show and late cancellation in writing and keep the definitions fixed. After launch, track delivery, completion, completion before the visit, and attendance.
Compare attendance before and after the change, not only completers against noncompleters. The completer comparison is likely to favor the survey because the patients who complete it differ from those who do not. In the Frye study, that comparison showed a large gap while the before-and-after comparison did not.
To put a financial value on fewer no-shows, use the business case guide. It explains why added capacity is not revenue unless the practice can fill and serve it.
