Skip to content

PCL-5 vs PC-PTSD-5: PTSD screening tools compared

The PC-PTSD-5 is a brief first-stage screen. The PCL-5 records all 20 DSM-5 PTSD symptoms. Learn what each tool and Survey Doctor actually report.

The PC-PTSD-5 is a brief first check of whether a fuller PTSD assessment may help. It asks five yes-or-no questions, and only if you report a traumatic event. The PCL-5 is longer and rates all 20 PTSD symptoms over the past month. Neither diagnoses PTSD, and a score on one cannot be converted into a score on the other.

How do the PCL-5 and PC-PTSD-5 differ?

The two questionnaires differ in length, answer format and what the score shows:

FeaturePC-PTSD-5PCL-5
First stepLifetime trauma-exposure questionKeep one traumatic event in mind
Scored symptom items520
Answer formatYes or no0 to 4
Score range0 to 50 to 80
Main useBrief first-stage screeningPast-month symptom measurement
What you getSymptom countTotal and four cluster scores

The PC-PTSD-5 was designed for primary care, to find people who may need a fuller assessment. The PCL-5 covers all 20 PTSD symptoms in the DSM-5, the manual used to diagnose PTSD.

How is each one scored?

The PC-PTSD-5 starts with an unscored question about lifetime trauma exposure. If the answer is no, the screen stops at 0. If the answer is yes, five past-month symptom questions follow, and each yes adds one point (VA PC-PTSD-5 reference).

A PC-PTSD-5 score of 0 can therefore mean either of two things. No traumatic event was reported, or one was reported and no symptom was marked yes. The number alone does not show which. It also does not show how strong a symptom is, because every answer is yes or no.

The official PCL-5 form asks you to note your worst traumatic event and keep it in mind. You then rate 20 past-month symptoms from 0 (not at all) to 4 (extremely), and the total adds all 20. The same answers also give four cluster scores: intrusion, avoidance, negative changes in thoughts and mood, and arousal or reactivity. If the event focus is unclear, complete the form with a professional.

The VA PCL-5 reference also describes a separate way to read the answers, which it calls a provisional diagnosis. It counts each answer of 2 or higher as a symptom and checks them against the DSM-5 pattern for PTSD. A total or cluster score alone does not show whether your answers fit that pattern. A professional can check it from your answer to each question.

What score suggests PTSD?

The VA gives a starting point for each. In a large VA primary care sample, a PC-PTSD-5 cutoff of 4 best balanced missed cases and false alarms. On the PCL-5, VA guidance suggests a cutoff between 31 and 33 for probable PTSD.

Neither number is universal, because a cutoff is a choice made for a particular group and purpose. Among women, a PC-PTSD-5 cutoff of 4 missed more cases, so a lower cutoff may suit some settings. A higher one may suit clinics where false alarms would stretch staff too thin. A lower cutoff finds more possible cases, but it also creates more incorrect positive screens.

The VA scoring guide also says the PCL-5 has no research-based severity ranges. Do not stretch the 31 to 33 range into official mild, moderate, probable or severe bands. Reaching a cutoff is never a diagnosis or a treatment order. Anyone who reaches one, or fits the symptom pattern, still needs a fuller assessment.

Neither questionnaire can decide whether an event meets the definition of trauma used for diagnosis. Neither checks every cause of similar symptoms, and neither can decide which treatment fits. A full evaluation also considers timing, daily life, other health conditions, substance use, medicine effects and your wider history. The score supports that work but does not replace it.

Which one should you take?

Take the PC-PTSD-5 for a quick first check. A low result does not rule out PTSD when concern remains. Take the PCL-5 if you want a record of all 20 symptoms, or a total to compare over time. It gives more detail, but it still cannot verify trauma exposure, daily impact or other causes.

You do not have to take both. After a positive PC-PTSD-5, the VA advises a clinical interview or, failing that, a questionnaire such as the PCL-5. A clinician may also start with the PCL-5 when trauma symptoms are already the focus. Clinics can set this up with the PTSD screening workflow.

Can you track your scores over time?

The PCL-5 can track symptoms over time. Repeat it with the same form, the same event in mind and the same past-month timeframe. The PC-PTSD-5 is a brief yes-or-no screen, so it is not a detailed severity tracker.

The VA notes that evidence on meaningful change is limited. It suggests a 10-point drop as a sign of response to treatment, as the PCL-5 score guide explains. A change alone does not prove reliable improvement or remission, so review it with the professional who knows your situation. A lower result is not a reason to stop care.

When should you talk to someone?

Talk with a professional if trauma-related symptoms affect your sleep, work, relationships, daily activities or safety. You do not need to cross a cutoff to ask for help.

If the questions bring up immediate safety concerns, seek support now.

If you need help now. In the US, Call 988 or text 988. Call 911 if you are in immediate danger. Outside the US, contact your local emergency number or find support in your country.

You can take the PC-PTSD-5 or the PCL-5 and bring the result to that conversation. The PC-PTSD-5 score guide and the PCL-5 score guide explain what each result means.

Track your mental health

Create an account to explore published assessments, automatic scoring, and score history

View plans

Get Survey Doctor updates

New assessments, features and articles, a few times a year. Unsubscribe at any time.

Survey Doctor provides published mental health questionnaires for informational purposes only. We work with physicians, but we are not your physician. A screening score is not a diagnosis, and nothing here is medical advice. Always talk to a qualified healthcare provider about your health.

Survey Doctor is operated by TeleEMG, LLC.